Accepting a New Stamping Die: What to Check at Tryout and Before Sign-Off

Nov 06, 2026

Leave a message

David Smith
David Smith
David is a senior engineer at Qingdao Hailong Machinery Technology Co., Ltd. With over 20 years of experience in automotive die design, he has played a crucial role in developing high - quality products for the company. He is well - versed in IATF16949/ISO9001 quality management system and is committed to ensuring product excellence.

Sign-off is the moment when risk moves from the tool maker to the buyer. Most disputes about a new die trace back to one of two things: acceptance criteria agreed too late, or a report that was received and never read.

Acceptance is not a single inspection. It is a sequence of defined outputs, and each one can be written into the purchase order before the tool is built.

 

Acceptance begins at T0, not at delivery

A typical sequence runs from design freeze to T0 first tryout, T1 correction, OTS sample, PPAP submission and SOP. Each stage should produce a document: the tryout log at T0, the corrected dimensional report at T1, the capability study at PPAP. If the purchase order names these outputs, the discussion at the end is about data, not about impressions.

 

At tryout: what to measure

Full dimensional report on the CTQ characteristics, measured on a CMM, with the datum scheme and the drawing revision stated on the report itself.

The material actually used. Grade and thickness, and whether it matches the production specification. A die that works in mild steel has not been proven in 590DP.

Process settings. Blank holder force, cushion pressure, draw bead arrangement and the tonnage curve per stroke. Without these the next run cannot be reproduced.

Edge condition. Burr height and burr direction on trimmed and pierced edges, measured rather than judged by touch.

Springback. Measured on parts that have been allowed to stabilize, on the characteristics where springback was expected.

Forming defects. Splits, wrinkles and thinning checked against the forming simulation, not only by visual inspection.

 

Capability and PPAP

Capability is calculated from a stable run, not from the six best parts of the first tryout. Automotive practice commonly requires Cpk of at least 1.33 on CTQ characteristics, but the figure that applies is the one in the customer's specific requirements. The PPAP submission level, from 1 to 5, is also set by the customer. Naming both in the RFQ is the simplest way to stop the documentation argument later.

 

Mechanical and tool-condition checks

These are the items that cost downtime six months after delivery: guide clearance, die spotting contact rate on the working surfaces, gas spring pressure and preload, safety blocks, lifting points marked with the tool weight, clamp slots that match the press T-slot, a clear identification plate, and a spare-parts list with recommended quantities.

 

The document package

Assembly drawing and detail drawings, in the agreed data format

Bill of materials, including standard-part references

Dimensional report and CMM data

Material certificates, heat-treatment and hardness records

Tryout log with process settings

PPAP or ISIR file at the agreed level

Spare-parts list and maintenance manual

Packing list and weight declaration

 

Red flags at sign-off

A dimensional report with no datum reference, or one measured against an earlier drawing revision. A capability figure quoted from ten parts. No record of tonnage or cushion settings. A spare-parts list that says "standard parts" and nothing more. A tool weight that appears for the first time on the shipping document.

 

The die is accepted on documents that can be checked later, not on how the last part looked. Hailong Machinery Technology Co., Ltd. delivers each die with a dimensional report, tryout log, material and hardness records and a spare-parts list, so acceptance is a review of the file rather than a negotiation at the press.

Send Inquiry